Terms of office exist in part
to protect officeholders and their respective policies from being immediately
overturned by an electorate acting without the benefit of inside information,
especially in foreign policy. In the space of several years, however, the role
of electoral judgment, including values, beliefs and even ideologies, can
outweigh the fact that voters are not privy to government-only information. The
free press can arguably provide enough information to legitimate popular
sovereignty even with respect for foreign policy. By 2026, reports of Russia’s
unprovoked military invasion of Ukraine for years, and of Israel’s genocidal
intent (and consequences) in Gaza (as determined by the UN) were sufficient that
virtually any American (or European) in denial of either atrocity could be
reckoned as being “off” mentally, at least with respect to allowing one’s ideology
to block facts on the ground. Those facts included arrest warrants issued by
the International Criminal Court for both Putin and Netanyahu. The two wholesale
instances of raw militaristic aggression naturally triggered the innate human
instinctual urge for justice around the world, and yet no “coalitions of the
willing” had been willing to go into Ukraine and Gaza to put an end to the unjustified,
excessive carnage. Even within the U.S., the federal government seemed cut off
from grassroot preferences to aid Ukraine and Gaza rather than enable Russia
and Israel. That the atrocities had been going on for years by 2026 means that
the American electorates had a legitimate say in their federal government’s foreign
policies, including on whether foreign aid should continue to be given to Israel,
regardless of which particular regime happens to be in power there.
The full essay is at "On the Gap between the People and the U.S. Government."